OK. With the help of Sir Scrub\n\n[URL]http://sirscrub.com/ripping_audio_with_dvd_decrypter.htm[/URL]\n\nand\n\nOn Sun, 4 Jan 2004 12:12:31 +0000 (UTC), "Stephen Stewart"\n\n<deleted>\n\n....instructions I was easily able to rip the enchanting KK audio\ncommentary from the DVD and listen to her "dulcet" voice until my\nheart's content. However I have been unable to duplicate those results\nsince.\n\nFirst with trying to rip the audio commentary from "All The Real\nGirls" and now "thirteen."\n\nI slipped the Pirates DVD back in the drive and was able to duplicate\nmy results which was pretty easy since under stream processing it\nactually says "director" and "alternate" commentary. Not so with the\nlast two efforts.\n\nFor example following the correct working instructions what I see when\nI put in the thirteen dvd is the choice of two AC3 channels to rip.\nThe first is 0x80 AC3 which as we know is the main dialog track from\nthe movie and as a test I ripped several of those chapters and they\nare indeed AC3 files and are from the main dialog track. Now here is\nthe problem. When I go to rip what can only be the commentary track\n0x93 Ac3 ( it lasts about an hour and 39 minutes ) I do not get ripped\nAC3 files but rather unplayable VOB files ( video has of course been\ndeselected )\n\nSoooo. What am I doing wrong and more importantly does anyone have the\n"thirteen" dvd and care to take a crack at ripping the audio\ncommentary and sharing your successful results. Thanks.