Initial Device Configuration - A panacea?

Discussion in 'Cisco' started by R I G Consulting, Inc., Mar 20, 2012.

  1. Greetings

    This is a broad question (again a sweeping question :) addressed to
    consumers of NMS as well as engineers involved with NMS software
    development. But specifically I would like to hear from NetOps.

    To set the context for this discussion -- by devices I mean anything
    and everything that can make a manageable network node: all-in-ones
    switches routers, modem racks, firewalls, encryption devices,
    modulators, etc. wireless devices such as tablets and phones...etc. If
    you wonder why I group all devices into one category, it is just for
    discussion sake, I look at them as if there was one manufacturer that
    made all of them, then they would keep *some* common minimum or a
    standard for the firmware footprint that went into it, in other words
    I am looking at it as if there some kind of standard that needs to be
    invented or available but no one implements it?

    Out of the box when new devices are added to a network, most or all
    devices support/use BOOTP, DHCP and or UPnP. This I call "Device
    Initiated Configuration Request" because the device initiates the
    request (even though UPnP may be peer-to-peer, it is still device
    initiated).

    Would it be convenient if we had something that is "NMS initiated"? By
    this I mean, the NMS software initiates the configuration instead of
    the device? I am guessing it would be convenient (1) because it
    reduces one more step NetOps/admins have to take in choosing BOOTP/
    DHCP/Manual and then let the configuration roll (BOOTP/DHCP) or if
    they selected "Manual" then key in the IP/mask/gateway address on the
    devices panel, whatever that is. (2) whenever there is a power cycling
    scenario involving hundreds or thousands of devices (as in a power
    outage in a center) and they power up again, it is presumed the
    configuration is recalled from the flash memory and no
    reconfigurations are required, but what if a total re-configuration
    (for example address range) was called for? Then Netops/Admin have to
    go through the pain of doing it all over as if each device was out of
    the box? What happens when the firmware is upgraded?

    Please respond with your logic whether you agree or disagree (that NMS
    initiated configuration is useful), especially if you are a NetOps. Or
    e-mail me directly your response to the e-mail address indicated
    below. This is to find if I need to consider a certain feature to be
    included in NMS product development.

    TIA
    Uma Sundaram
    http://www.rigconsulting.com
    [email protected][nospam]yahoo.com
     
    R I G Consulting, Inc., Mar 20, 2012
    #1
    1. Advertisements

Ask a Question

Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?

You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments (here). After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.