increased color saturation solves hyper-contrast problems

Discussion in 'Digital Photography' started by David Virgil Hobbs, Oct 26, 2004.


    Sometimes in digital photography, you have the problem of getting
    exaggerated contrast in portraits. This problem is compounded by
    imperfections in the setting of white balance. Photos featuring excess
    contrast can be improved by increasing color saturation levels and
    then adjusting hue to compensate for the color changes produced by the
    changes in color saturation level. This approach can solve problems
    that you would not be able to solve using contrast adjustment controls
    that are specifically designed to adjust contrast.

    You can read plenty of attempts to describe what happens when the
    color saturation of a photograph is discussed on the internet. I
    present to you the simple truths it seems are too hard to find at
    these sites. A point of color in a digital image is determined by the
    luminosity of red, green, and blue at a point in the image. Various
    brightnesses of red green and blue combine to produce all the colors
    you see in digital images. The red green and blue levels for any point
    of color are measured from 0-255. When color saturation is increased,
    generally speaking, of these three color components in a color point,
    color components that are above the average luminosity of the three
    components in terms of luminosity, are increased in luminosity, while
    color components that are below the average luminosity of the color
    point are decreased in luminosity, with the rule being that the
    greater the divergence of the R G or B color element's luminosity from
    the average luminosity of the three R red G green and B blue elements
    in the color point, the greater the change in luminosity produced in
    the R G or B element in the color point by an increase in color
    saturation level.

    Increasing color saturation in an image, when two different colors are
    increased in saturation by an equal amount, can decrease the
    difference or contrast between the two colors, because the dominant
    brightest color (R red or G green or B blue) in the RGB spec of the
    two different colors is pushed to near the 255 maximum in both colors,
    as a result of which differences in luminosity of, for example, the R
    specs found in the different colors in the image decrease resulting in
    decreased contrast.

    When there is an increase in the luminosity of the dominant color in
    an RGB color point, if the color points vary from each other less in
    terms of the R G or B color element in the color point that increases
    in luminosity, than they do in terms of the R G or B elements in the
    color point that decrease in luminosity, as a result of the increase
    in color saturation, this can result in decreased contrast because the
    R G or B elements in the color points that contrast less from point to
    point in the image become more dominant, while the R G or B elements
    that contrast more from point to point become less dominant.

    Since the increase in color saturation pushes the (R G or B) colors in
    a color point that are relatively weak compared to other R G or B
    elements in the color point, in terms of luminosity, to even lower
    levels, this can result in a decrease in contrast when the major
    source of the excessive contrast is found in RGB elements in a color
    point that are relatively low in luminosity compared to the other RGB
    elements in the color point.

    You cannot just add up the differences in the numerical RGB specs in
    two different colors to determine how much those colors vary, because
    the sub-dominant colors (lower luminosity than the dominant color in
    the color point) in the rgb color points (points which are composed of
    red green and blue in various luminosities) have less impact on the
    color presented by the color point, the dimmer they are.

    There is less difference between RGB 255-70-0 and 255-0-0 than there
    is between 255-255-0 and 255-220-0; at lower levels of brightness in
    an RGB element in a color point, changes in the luminosity of the RGB
    element in the color point, change the color less than at higher
    levels of RGB element brightness.

    Thus it would appear that problems when a camera is exaggerating
    contrast, could be: the camera is producing excess differentiation
    from color point to color point in terms of the brightness of the
    brightest r or g or b component of the color point; the camera is not
    letting the most dominant components of the rgb points, which vary
    from point to point in the image less than other components of the rgb
    points, be bright enough compared to the other R G or B elements in
    the color point; and the camera is letting the subdominant elements of
    the RGB points in the photos, the colors that vary from each other
    more from point to point than the dominant R or G or B color in the
    color points, manifest themselves relatively speaking too brightly and
    impact the points of color excessively.

    Such hyper-contrast problems might be caused in part by incorrect
    white balance settings. Imperfect white balance setting, common when
    fluorescent tungsten and flash all combine to contribute to the
    lighting of a photo, can contribute to the problem of the exaggeration
    of the luminosity of for example the G or green element in RGB color
    points, resulting in contrast exaggeration which can be solved through
    color saturation enhancement such as I have been discussing.

    Incandescent and fluorescent white balance used in flash conditions,
    produce bluish tints; incandescent and flash white balance used in
    fluorescent conditions produce yellowish and greenish tints; and flash
    and fluorescent white balance used in tungsten conditions produces
    orangish (red combined with yellow which is a mix of red and green)

    Thus fluorescent light photographed using flash white balance will
    produce yellow (a combo of red and green) and green tints; and
    tungsten light photographed using flash white balance will produce
    orangish (a combination of red and green) tints. So you can see how a
    camera overemphasizing the luminosity of the G or green elements in
    the RGB color points could lead to an exaggeration of contrast in
    flesh tones in which the R is most dominant, followed by the G Green
    and then the B blue; and you can see how such could be solved through
    increases in color saturation decreasing the relative luminosity of
    subdominant elements such as G Green elements in color points.

    When brightening light is shed on R red dominated faces, the
    brightening effect of the lights leads to an increase in the G green
    and B blue elements in the color points. You can see this from the
    way, if you take basic red, (R-255, B-0, G-0) pushing the B and G
    values higher and higher will make the color look brighter and whiter,
    make it look more and more like an overexposed photo or a photo
    subjected to excessive light. Thus you can see that light, which makes
    objects closer to white, and which is used to compensate for the
    limited light sensitivity of a camera compared to the eye, will tend
    to increase (in certain common R red dominated flesh color tones) the
    brightness of the sub-dominant G green and B blue elements to the
    point where they, mixing with the red elements of the color points,
    exaggerate contrast; and you can see how increasing color saturation,
    resulting in a decrease in the relative luminosity of the G and B
    elements in the color points, could reduce unwanted exaggeration in

    To reproduce what you see with the eye in limited light, you often
    have to, when using the camera, exaggerate the power of every light
    source you see with your eye in the natural light, while keeping the
    relative power of the various light sources compared to each other,
    the same as found in the natural scene.

    Thus, the camera is more sensitive to the blues and greens that
    dominate light from light sources (at least in terms of the effect of
    such light on color points that are R red dominated) than the human
    eye is. Therefore, after all is said and done, one can end up with
    portraiture that is unsatisfactory due to an excess of contrast,
    because it is the B blue and G greens in the RGB color points, that
    creat the excessive contrast, since the camera is compared to the
    human eye hypersensitive to them, and records them too emphatically or
    luminously or brightly; but one can recover from the problem by
    increasing the color saturation in the image so that the contrast
    producing G green and B blue elements are diminished in their ability
    to influence the colors produced by RGB color points.

    @2004 David Virgil Hobbs
    David Virgil Hobbs, Oct 26, 2004
    1. Advertisements

  2. David Virgil Hobbs

    bob Guest

    (David Virgil Hobbs) wrote in
    In "good" editing software, you can also convert the image to Lab mode and
    adjust the luminosity seperatly from the color. It's also a handy mode for
    adjusting noise and sharpness. You can blur the color chanel with the noise
    (usually a OR b, but sometimes both), and you can sharpen the luminosity.
    The resulting image is both sharper and smoother. Something very difficult
    to do in RGB mode.

    bob, Oct 26, 2004
    1. Advertisements

Ask a Question

Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?

You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments (here). After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.