Design By Cartel

Discussion in 'NZ Computing' started by Lawrence D'Oliveiro, Jan 6, 2009.

  1. Everybody's heard of "Design By Committee", where a bunch of representatives
    from different groups get together to put together a specification for
    something that's agreeable to everybody. Frequently the result is something
    so complex, unwieldy and obtuse, that it gives reasonably intelligent
    people the screaming heebie-jeebies just to look at it. Sometimes, it's
    even a flop. Other times, it ends up being a millstone around the neck of
    everybody who has to use or implement the spec.

    I've come across something even worse: it's "Design By Cartel". This is
    where the members of the committee stand to profit from licensing patents
    related to the spec. This means that the design process turns into a
    jostling match for everybody to push as much of their own patented
    technologies into the final spec as they can.

    It appears this is what happened to some extent with the DVD-Video spec
    <>. I've been trying to find
    publicly-available information there is about it, as part of making sense
    of the dvdauthor source code, and what I've found is an amazing number of
    complications: two different clock references (one 27MHz and one 90kHz),
    two different places to store button colour information, two different ways
    to represent audio streams, oh, and watch out what happens to button
    coordinates when widescreen footage is being shown letterboxed on a 4:3
    screen--it's just mind-boggling.

    I guess they were lucky that DVD-Video succeeded as well as it did. I think
    we're seeing the same sort of process with HD-DVD and Blu-Ray, only the
    promoters of those formats haven't been quite so lucky.
    Lawrence D'Oliveiro, Jan 6, 2009
    1. Advertisements

Ask a Question

Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?

You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments (here). After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.