Backward North America still...backward!

Discussion in 'DVD Video' started by Richard, Aug 14, 2004.

  1. Richard

    Richard Guest

    In a video store the other day, a gentleman was asked if he
    wanted the WS or P&S version of the movie; He chose the P&S.
    This is STILL happening for one major reason; North Americans are WAY
    behind in technology compared to the Japanese and Europeans.
    As long as they KEEP pushing 4:3 TVs and KEEP showing 4:3 TV programs,
    this warped preference of the unsophisticated video viewer will continue.
    Digital TV still has less than 10% penetration and they KEEP pushing out the
    HDTV broadcast mandates in North America. It's pathetic.
    Richard, Aug 14, 2004
    1. Advertisements

  2. Richard

    Biz Guest

    Which country has the largest population, AND the largest installed base of
    4:3 tvs in the world? Unless you have plenty of disposable income, you just
    dont go out a buy new widescreen HDTV's becuase they are there. WHen you
    are ready to replace your existing tv, you have to weigh the price vs. what
    you can afford. The cost differential is still pretty high in NOrth America
    as well. Its just a simple matter of money mostly.
    Biz, Aug 14, 2004
    1. Advertisements

  3. Richard

    Black Locust Guest

    Was he asked if he wanted pan & scan or "full screen"? I'm guessing it
    was the latter. If the store clerk had asked the Joe Schmo if he wanted
    a P&S version the Joe Schmo would have likely just given the clerk a
    blank stare. This is just a rough estimate, but it seems to me at least
    8 out of 10 people have no idea what pan & scan is despite the fact that
    the term has existed since the 1970's. Pretty sad. People need to be
    taught what P&S is. I wish I could make everyone I know sit down and
    watch that "Why Letterbox?" featurette on the Die Hard DVD. Infact I
    made my mother watch it just so she truly understood what P&S is.

    But believe me, it used to be much much worse just a few years ago. Take
    a time machine back to 1993 and go into a video store. The clerk would
    have handed the gentlemen a pan & scan VHS tape and the option of a
    widescreen version wouldn't have even been available, let alone brought
    up by either one of them.
    Black Locust, Aug 14, 2004
  4. Richard

    Jay Stewart Guest

    Were you there when this happened? Did you speak up?
    Jay Stewart, Aug 14, 2004
  5. Richard

    TB Guest

    "Richard" whined:
    BFD. Most people should be so lucky that their biggest worry is stupid
    aspect ratios on tvs.

    TB, Aug 14, 2004
  6. Why is it, that everytime some guys discuss something, some looney has
    to show up shouting "BFD". Why the hell do you think AR is their "biggest"
    worry?? This is and butchered movies are one big problem
    in the US home video market, but it's by far not the biggest.

    Ronald Stoehr, Aug 14, 2004
  7. Richard

    Richard Guest

    Yes, the P&S was my modification. I refuse to use a term that makes it sound
    like the version he wanted has any merit.
    Richard, Aug 14, 2004
  8. Richard

    Richard Guest

    Did I speak up? No. I used to when this happened, but it's gotten to
    the point where those who still choose P&S are simply too stupid to be
    convinced the correct aspect ratio version is worth seeing and the proprietors
    of video stores are simply trying to be all things to all people in order to
    maximize their sales. Kind of like Hollywood and PG rated movies.
    Richard, Aug 14, 2004
  9. Richard

    Mark Spatny Guest

    Biz, says...
    Not the United States, so how does this relate to the original post?
    Mark Spatny, Aug 15, 2004
  10. Richard

    Biz Guest

    Sorry should have been installed user base of tvs and/or dvd players. Of
    course you knew that, but were too much of a smart ass to just politely
    correct me.
    Biz, Aug 15, 2004
  11. Richard

    Mark Jones Guest

    How was anyone supposed to know that? I wondered what
    the reference to China was about.
    Mark Jones, Aug 15, 2004
  12. Richard

    John Savard Guest

    Why on earth would anyone want to force people to run out and spend lots of money
    on a new TV set, when they already have a perfectly good one?

    At least America is a real democracy, where the political elites don't think they
    can bully ordinary people! (Well, aside from the Supreme Court, of course.)

    This is why we have loonies, but you don't have Susan B. Anthony dollars
    replacing your dollar bill.

    John Savard
    John Savard, Aug 16, 2004
  13. Richard

    Mark Spatny Guest

    Biz, says...
    Which I still don't know is the United States. I have no data one way or
    another, and I wouldn't assume that the US has the largest installed
    base. For all I know China has more TVs. Even if fewer TVs per capita,
    the larger population and the proliferation of pirated DVDs may make it
    a much larger DVD market.
    Mark Spatny, Aug 16, 2004
  14. This was the main motivation for buying a laser disc player in
    '91. Only way to get widesceen movies then.
    Scott Streeter, Aug 16, 2004
  15. Maybe when movie studios start droping using that false lable "Full Frame"
    and start calling it what it really is, along with including information
    releases describing to people why Widescreen is better then maybe just
    maybe people might start waking up.
    Brian The Demolition Man Little, Aug 17, 2004
  16. Richard

    Eric R. Guest

    You tell 'em John! Fight the power!!

    Eric R., Aug 17, 2004
  17. Richard

    Jordan Lund Guest

    I saw the same thing... only it was worse... the guy actually said "I
    don't want the top and bottom chopped off..."


    In defense of 4:3 sets though... I am going to buy a big-screen 4:3.
    Why? I have a lot of video games and they're all 4:3. In fact, I
    probably spend more time playing games than watching DVDs. Yes, I'll
    make sure that it does proper 16:9 conversion... But while I'm not
    distracted by having black bars on movies, I think I would be
    distracted by having black side panels on video games.

    Of course if they made TVs in anything other than silver right now it
    wouldn't be as bad. :^)

    - Jordan
    Jordan Lund, Aug 18, 2004
  18. I actually own a 32 inch HDTV myself, for the reasons you just
    mentioned. Tho I'll admit playing "Enter The Matrix" on my XBox
    at 1080i is very beautiful even if the game itself isn't so. ;-)
    Brian The Demolition Man Little, Aug 19, 2004
    1. Advertisements

Ask a Question

Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?

You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments (here). After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.