«

Lets say we run: window.alert = function() { };

Is there anyway to 'restore' the original alert() method or is it gone
forever?

I know you can do window.alert = Window.prototype.alert, but lets say
you also set Window.prototype.alert = function() { } or lets say we're
in Opera, which doesnt have a Window "class".

steve dp wrote:
> Lets say we run: window.alert = function() { };
>
> Is there anyway to 'restore' the original alert() method or is it gone
> forever?

Are you trying to keep a possibility to restore alert() or are you
trying to eliminate such possibility?

In any case by doing window.alert = function() { }; you are not
overriding the native code, you merely replace the reference. So it's
enough to:

window.nativeAlert = window.alert;
window.alert = function() { };
....
window.alert = window.nativeAlert;

If you want to shadow the native method, when my strike back hack
would be to create new hidden iframe - which is window by its nature -
and use its fresh 'non-spooffed' references.

steve dp wrote:
> Lets say we run: window.alert = function() { };
>
> Is there anyway to 'restore' the original alert() method or is it gone
> forever?

No, it hasn't 'gone' anywhere. You've just overridden the reference to it.
I guess a cynic might say that if you remove all references it'll be
swallowed by garbage collection but I doubt that can happen with
in-built host objects.


> I know you can do window.alert = Window.prototype.alert, but lets say
> you also set Window.prototype.alert = function() { } or lets say we're
> in Opera, which doesnt have a Window "class".

Store a reference to it, then restore it when you're finished. Play with this:

<p>Test window.alert</p>
<input type="button" value="test alert"
onclick="alert('hey, it worked');">

<p>Store a reference to window.alert</p>
<input type="button" value="store reference"
onclick="window.keptAlertRef = window.alert;">

<p>Over-ride window.alert</p>
<input type="button" value="over-ride alert"
onclick="window.alert = null;">

<p>Restore window.alert from stored reference</p>
<input type="button" value="restore reference"
onclick="window.alert = window.keptAlertRef;">



--
Rob

RobG wrote:

> steve dp wrote:
>> Lets say we run: window.alert = function() { };
>>
>> Is there anyway to 'restore' the original alert() method or is it gone
>> forever?
>
> No, it hasn't 'gone' anywhere. You've just overridden the reference to
> it. I guess a cynic might say that if you remove all references it'll be
> swallowed by garbage collection but I doubt that can happen with
> in-built host objects.

It is just another host Function(-like) object that was created when the
script engine was invoked; its only specialty is that it _contains_ a call
to a built-in method. It is not the object referred to by `window' that
would be GC'd then, or the called built-in method, only one of `window''s
methods. So it is perfectly reasonable if that would be marked for GC
once there were no more references to it. It is therefore also perfectly
reasonable to assume that it would be restored if the document was
reloaded, which is in fact what happens.

BTW, I fail to find anything cynical about garbage collection other than
"Is it again /my/ turn to take out the garbage? (sigh)"


Regards,
PointedEars