On Jun 1, 1:12*pm, "iC and iC++" <mahd...@gmail.com> wrote:
> On May 30, 11:15*pm, spinoza1111 <spinoza1...@yahoo.com> wrote:
>
>
>
>
>
> >http://catless.ncl.ac.uk/Risks/26.07.html
>
> > Peter Neumann has apologized for publishing my article on Schildt. He
> > now says he feels it was not appropriate.
>
> > My guess is that he was spammed by protests from people invested in
> > the anti-Schildt cause.
>
> > I have sent a private email to Neumann, requesting a retraction "of
> > the retraction" based on the fact that while he sent me a private
> > email saying it would be published in 26.06 because of its length, he
> > did not make any negative comments as to whether it was appropriate. I
> > said that people like Schildt have a right not to be attacked based on
> > shibboleths, by ignorant individuals without standing.
>
> > This issue is not going away.
>
> Who is Schildt? - Hide quoted text -
Herb Schildt is a somewhat notorious author of a number of popular but
*deeply* flawed books on C and C++. Most of these works are marked
"Not Recommended" by the Association of C and C++ Users
(
www.accu.org), and a number of other reviewers (including Peter
Seebach and Clive Feather) have pointed out some of the errors on
their own websites. I had a copy of the 1st edition of "C: The
Complete Reference" back when I was in college (1986-89 timeframe)
that eventually wound up in the trash; many of the examples wouldn't
compile, and the ones that did had numerous runtime errors. It didn't
help that he explained basic concepts incorrectly and confused DOS-
specific extensions with the core library. The current (4th) edition
still has problems.
Despite this, Schildt is held up as an authority on C programming. Go
figure.
> What is Shibboleths?
As is being used here, a shibboleth is a cultural feature that
identifies you as part of a group, usually in the form of a word or
phrase, although it could be something like a secret handshake or
other specific ritual.