thingy wrote:
> Stephen Worthington wrote:
>> On Fri, 02 Jun 2006 16:16:38 +1200, thingy <>
>> wrote:
>>
>>
>>> XPD wrote:
>>>
>>>> "thingy" <> wrote in message
>>>> news:6mh4l3-...
>>>>
>>>>
>>>>> looking for something low cost, DSE used to do units that bolt
>>>>> under a hd and blow air, had a wave like csa....
>>>>>
>>>>> Anybdoy sell something similar in WGTN?
>>>>>
>>>>> regards
>>>>>
>>>>> Thing
>>>>
>>>>
>>>> http://www.ascent.co.nz/ProductSpeci...?ItemID=344062
>>>> Looks purdy 
>>>>
>>>> Or maybe this is more what ya after...
>>>>
>>>> http://www.ascent.co.nz/ProductSpeci...?ItemID=344064
>>>>
>>>>
>>>
>>> Thanks, first one takes too much space, second might be Ok, except
>>> I'd need 5.....
>>>
>>> regards
>>>
>>> thing
>>
>>
>> The first one is the same size as a normal 5.25" external drive bay.
>> Works nicely so far - I have two. I used to have a couple of those
>> DSE ones, but the fans in them turned out to be complete crap - they
>> died after about 2.5 years operation. Maybe that is why they do not
>> sell them anymore. The rotary fan in the Evercool one is a much
>> higher spec unit, and very quiet. I am just waiting for my DSE units
>> in the other PC to crap out now.
>
> Trouble is I have 5 drives in the 5 bays, so the dse units are ideal.
>
> For my new box these might be ideal though
I have one of the DSE ones and would have to second Stephen's comment on the
fans. Mine are still going strong but only because I lubricated then with
some molybdenum grease after they started to make a racket, at about 5
months old.
Actually they're not that efficient IMO. Certainly better than nothing but,
unless you remove the label from your HDD and use a smear of heat-transfer
compound over the whole area (and rub it into the cooler contact surface as
it is quite rough, has coarse machining marks) it's not that great.
If I was only using the one, and being on a budget, that second link from
Ascent looks good. The DSE one was something like $40+ anyway and the
little, fragile filter thingy on the front broke fairly quickly. Also, the
DSE ones are *very* noisy.
The one in the first link looks good, especially if you can stack them and
retain efficiency. I'm not sure what they mean by a "turbo cross-flow fan"
but if it's anything like this:
http://www.flickr.com/photos/87845368@N00/159015862/
And if they're stackable without any reduction in efficiency then they would
be great. Shame there isn't a cheaper model though, without the display/fan
speed controller. Just a housing with a fan like the one pictured in the
link would be great. There is anough software to monitor HDD temps without
having to have displays on the front of the case.
--
Shaun.