> probably not but I like his dogged persistence regardless of the outcome
Never retreat, never surrender.
On November 27, 1950, the Chinese Communists launched a massive
counterattack against the X Corps and cut the road stretching 80 miles back
to Hungnam in several places, trapping the Marines. After conferring with
Almond, Smith decided to withdraw his division to Hungnam. Almond told Smith
to leave his heavy equipment and artillery. But Smith, never doubting the
ability of the Marines to fight their way out of the Chinese entrapment, was
determined to conduct "an orderly and honorable withdrawal" and bring out
his equipment, wounded, and even as many of his dead as possible. Regrouping
his forward units and attached Army units at Hagaru-ri, he withdrew from the
Changjin area, all the time making sure that he controlled the hills
overlooking the road. Opposed by no less than eight Chinese divisions,
fighting through numerous enemy roadblocks as they made their way south, and
forced to endure subzero temperatures, the Marines suffered thousands of
battle casualties and cases of frostbite. Yet Smith's dogged leadership and
crucial air support enabled them to maintain their tactical integrity and
inflict 25,000 casualties on the Chinese. Asked by a journalist December 6,
if the Marines were retreating, Smith, in a widely circulated quotation that
earned him great acclaim at home, defiantly replied: "We are not retreating,
we are just advancing in a different direction." By December 11, after 13
harrowing days, Smith's force finally arrived at Hungnam, where his division
was evacuated by sea. In a brilliant feat of military management, Smith had
saved his division and given American morale a desperately needed boost at a
critical time in the Korean War.