Andreas Leitgeb wrote:
> Lew <> wrote:
>> Sure, call me to account for calling Christians "annoying" (and I really mean
>> only those who insist on pitching their beliefs to me - which my own mother
>> does to me, and it annoys me, but I love my mother).
>
> As you perhaps noticed, I made my point substituting "Christians"
> with "*whoever*", so it wasn't about how christians really are, but
> how un-nice it was of you to idly throw insults at a group, of which
> only a (relatively) very small number of individuals might actually
> deserve it.
> If *all* Christians were like that, you wouldn't get to write this,
> because every five seconds, one of them would ring your doorbell 
> (Neither would I get to comment on it for just the same reason)
All right. Point taken. I should have said that the proselytizing was as
annoying as most Christians'.
Who are only reacting to an institutionalized policy of proselytization into
which they are indoctrinated as a regular part of their dogma.
And for which behavior Christian sects are infamous.
But I never made the claim that it applied to all Christians; you added that,
not me.
These observations do not apply to "whomever" but specifically to Christian
sects. I reject the substitution of "whomever" since my comment was specific
to Christianity (as an organized religion).
I reject the accusation of bigotry because the comment was based on experience
and observation, and because I do not apply it to all followers of Christ.
I accept the criticism for making my comment too general.
Maybe if my doorbell had not been rung, or my person accosted, so often by
these annoying proselytes I would have had no cause for complaint. I cannot
tell you how many times I have been asked if I have "accepted the Lord Jesus
Christ as my personal savior". Maybe it's because I have lived in urban areas
that I got more overwhelmed by this than you have been.
It is an observed fact that Christian sects encourage their membership to
proselytize, and that many of their followers do so. I cannot believe you seek
to imply otherwise. This behavior exists, and it annoys me.
I never claimed it was universal. That is a calumny perpetrated by those whose
feelings were tromped by my accusation. I claimed that Christians engage in
this behavior, not that all Christians do. I stand by that claim. Furthermore,
I claim that it is a distinguishing feature of Christianity, historically and
contemporaneously, to proselytize. It is an inherent part of the dogma (mental
oppression) perpetrated by many Christian sects. It is anything but bigotry;
it is a grounded assessment supportable by objective evidence.
So stop disingenuously pretending it isn't so.
If other Christians feel upset by this, then encourage the ones who give you a
bad name to stop their annoying behavior.
-- Lew