Confused. Need Help!

I can't figure out why these three snippits of code are not equivalent..
Can someone show me the correct way to do this... (Cut and paste sample code
follows).

@tbl is array of array refs:

This works like I want it to:
foreach (@tbl) {
my $key = shift @$_;
$hash{$key} = [@$_];
}

This duplicates the key:
foreach (@tbl) {
$hash{shift @$_} = [@$_];
}

And why can't I say (produces only last entry; I know this is the
define/init syntax, isn't there an append flavor like .= ?)
foreach (@tbl) {
%hash = (shift @$_ => [@$_]);
}

--- Test program follows: ----

#!/usr/bin/perl -w
use strict;

my @tbl = (
[ "Larry Wall", "Perl Author", "555-0101" ],
[ "Tim Bunce", "DBI Author", "555-0202" ],
[ "Randal Schwartz", "Guy at Large", "555-0303" ],
[ "Doug MacEachern", "Apache Man", "555-0404" ]
);

my %hash = ();


# this doesn't work
foreach (@tbl) {
$hash{shift @$_} = [@$_];
}

foreach (keys %hash) {
print $_, "=>", join " ", @{$hash{$_}}, "\n";
}


@tbl = (
[ "Larry Wall", "Perl Author", "555-0101" ],
[ "Tim Bunce", "DBI Author", "555-0202" ],
[ "Randal Schwartz", "Guy at Large", "555-0303" ],
[ "Doug MacEachern", "Apache Man", "555-0404" ]
);

%hash = ();

# this works
foreach (@tbl) {
my $key = shift @$_;
$hash{$key} = [@$_];
}

foreach (keys %hash) {
print $_, "=>", join " ", @{$hash{$_}}, "\n";
}

Cobra Pilot

Hi,

First, all of the snippets modify @tbl, or rather, the arrays referenced
in @tbl.

Cobra Pilot wrote:

> I can't figure out why these three snippits of code are not equivalent..
> Can someone show me the correct way to do this... (Cut and paste sample code
> follows).
>
> @tbl is array of array refs:
>
> This works like I want it to:
> foreach (@tbl) {
> my $key = shift @$_;
> $hash{$key} = [@$_];
> }
The expression [@$_] can be replaced with simply $_.

>
> This duplicates the key:
> foreach (@tbl) {
> $hash{shift @$_} = [@$_];
> }
The array [@$_] is created first, the @$_ is shifted. This means the
array [@$_] is not shifted. If you use $_ instead of [@$_], you get what
you want.

>
> And why can't I say (produces only last entry; I know this is the
> define/init syntax, isn't there an append flavor like .= ?)
> foreach (@tbl) {
> %hash = (shift @$_ => [@$_]);
> }
>
Try: %hash = ( %hash, shift @$_ => $_ );
That's the best I can think of.

BTW, you can use Data:umper to view complex data structures:
use Data:umper;
print &Dumper( \%hash );