Table/table rows/table data tag question?

Hi, my goal is to extract data from cells within tables from certain pages
(sportsbooks odds)!

I'm using java to achieve this, I get the source of the page, place it in a
string and pass that string (basically source of the html page) to methods
that cut it out sequentially.

First they find whatever it is between
<table.....any text including data, attributes and other tags up
until...../table>

Whatever is in there belongs to table 1 and that substring is cut out and
passed to another method that finds

<tr............anything..................../tr>

that's row 1, that substring is cut out and passed to another method that
finds

<td...............anything............../td> and finally strips other tags
and extracts data.

Finally every cell has its data, table number, row number and cell number.



The program works for the great majority of pages I'm trying to extract data
from. It obviously fails when it encounters table within table

<table (1).....
<table (2 within table 1)....
..........
.../table (2)>
/table (1)>

becuse it cuts from first <table opening tag until first /table> closing
tag. That's also a problem I can deal with.


NOW, THE PROBLEM!

But one particular page is giving me headache. I noticed my programm wrongly
counts cells, rows, misplaces data etc. I designed a method TO COUNT EACH
OCCURENCE OF opening and closing <table <tr and <td tags and found out that
NUMBER OF OPENING AND CLOSING TAGS IS NOT THE SAME and therefore I can't
design the programm that can correctly find what I want.

THE QUESTION IS: How is it possible and how does IE know where one table
(table row or cell) starts and where it ends and is it possible that some
<table <tr or <td tags actually only serve to describe attributes of that
table or row, if so how can I recognize them?


Big thanks to anyone who just reads this !

Rio

So you are writing your own HTML parser?

Why not just use the provided ones? (I'm pretty sure there's one in the JRE
already, in javax.text or somewhere). This will deal with nested tables etc
for you.

If the pages are XHTML, you could even use a generic XML parser, such as
Xerces. One of the advantages of XHTML is easy parsing with generic tools.

Rio wrote:

> THE QUESTION IS: How is it possible and how does IE know where one table
> (table row or cell) starts and where it ends and is it possible that some
> <table <tr or <td tags actually only serve to describe attributes of that
> table or row, if so how can I recognize them?

The closing tag for table rows and cells is optional. Browsers understand
this.

As you parse a td element if you encounter a <td> or a <tr> or a </tr> then
you *imply* a </td> for the td element. Rows are easier, as you parse the tr
element if you encounter a <tr> or a </table> then imply a </tr>.

--
Cheers
Richard.

Thanks a lot for the reply that's really helpful, how about table tag, are
they supposed to be closed properly, if yes how is it possible to have
unequal number of opening and closing table tags?


> The closing tag for table rows and cells is optional. Browsers understand
> this.
>
> As you parse a td element if you encounter a <td> or a <tr> or a </tr>
then
> you *imply* a </td> for the td element. Rows are easier, as you parse the
tr
> element if you encounter a <tr> or a </table> then imply a </tr>.
>
> --
> Cheers
> Richard.
>
>

Rio wrote:

[top posting corrected]

> > The closing tag for table rows and cells is optional. Browsers
understand
> > this.
> >
> > As you parse a td element if you encounter a <td> or a <tr> or a </tr>
> then
> > you *imply* a </td> for the td element. Rows are easier, as you parse
the
> tr
> > element if you encounter a <tr> or a </table> then imply a </tr>.

> Thanks a lot for the reply that's really helpful, how about table tag,

Element. You are talking about the table *element*. It has an opening tag
and a closing tag and, between these, some content.

> are
> they supposed to be closed properly,

Check the specification.
http://www.w3.org/TR/html4/struct/ta...tml#edef-TABLE

It says there tat the end tag is required.

> if yes how is it possible to have
> unequal number of opening and closing table tags?

The spec says the table element must be closed. This does not mean that
authors *will* close them. The result will be up to browser error
correction.

--
Cheers
Richard.