Velocity Reviews

Velocity Reviews (http://www.velocityreviews.com/forums/index.php)
-   C++ (http://www.velocityreviews.com/forums/f39-c.html)
-   -   Sorting a map by value (http://www.velocityreviews.com/forums/t285185-sorting-a-map-by-value.html)

Kevin W. 08-24-2004 07:55 AM

Sorting a map by value
 
How do I sort a map by the value, rather than the key? (either
automatically or with the sort function.)

--
Kevin W :-)
Opera/CSS/webdev blog: http://www.exclipy.com/
Using Opera: http://www.opera.com/m2/

Rolf Magnus 08-24-2004 09:48 AM

Re: Sorting a map by value
 
Kevin W. wrote:

> How do I sort a map by the value, rather than the key? (either
> automatically or with the sort function.)


You can't sort maps. They are always automatically sorted by key.


tom_usenet 08-24-2004 11:58 AM

Re: Sorting a map by value
 
On Tue, 24 Aug 2004 07:55:19 GMT, "Kevin W." <contact@in.sig> wrote:

>How do I sort a map by the value, rather than the key? (either
>automatically or with the sort function.)


You can't - std::map has an invariant that it is sorted by key. You'll
have to copy into a vector or similar first, or perhaps maintain two
parallel maps (key->value and value->key).

Tom

Daniel T. 08-24-2004 12:09 PM

Re: Sorting a map by value
 
"Kevin W." <contact@in.sig> wrote:

> How do I sort a map by the value, rather than the key? (either
> automatically or with the sort function.)


First start with a test:

int main() {
map< char, int > current;
current['a'] = 5;
current['b'] = 4;
current['c'] = 3;

map< int, char > other = converse_map( current );

map< int, char >::iterator begin( other.begin() );
assert( begin->first == 3 );
assert( begin->second == 'c' );
++begin;
assert( begin->first == 4 );
assert( begin->second == 'b' );
++begin;
assert( begin->first == 5 );
assert( begin->second == 'a' );
cout << "OK";
}

When the above prints "OK" you know you are done. Now write the
'converse_map' function...

map< int, char > converse_map( const map< char, int >& o )
{
map< int, char > result;
for ( map< char, int >::const_iterator begin( o.begin() );
begin != o.end(); ++begin )
result.insert( make_pair( begin->second, begin->first ) );
return result;
}

Then turn it into a template...

template < typename T, typename U >
map< U, T > converse_map( const map< T, U >& o )
{
map< U, T > result;
for ( typename map< T, U >::const_iterator begin( o.begin() );
begin != o.end(); ++begin )
result.insert( make_pair( begin->second, begin->first ) );
return result;
}

=?iso-8859-1?Q?Joaqu=EDn=20M=AA=20L=F3pez=20Mu=F1oz?= 08-24-2004 01:34 PM

Re: Sorting a map by value
 
tom_usenet ha escrito:

> On Tue, 24 Aug 2004 07:55:19 GMT, "Kevin W." <contact@in.sig> wrote:
>
> >How do I sort a map by the value, rather than the key? (either
> >automatically or with the sort function.)

>
> You can't - std::map has an invariant that it is sorted by key. You'll
> have to copy into a vector or similar first, or perhaps maintain two
> parallel maps (key->value and value->key).
>


Boost.MultiIndex (to appear promptly in Boost 1.32, online docs
already available at boost-consulting.com/boost/libs/multi_index) can
be used to construct such a bidirectional map easily. This is shown in one

of the examples at

boost-consulting.com/boost/libs/multi_index/doc/examples.html#example4

Regards,

Joaquín M López Muñoz
Telefónica, Investigación y Desarrollo


Thomas Matthews 08-24-2004 02:41 PM

Re: Sorting a map by value
 
Kevin W. wrote:

> How do I sort a map by the value, rather than the key? (either
> automatically or with the sort function.)
>


The map data structure is an association between a key
and a value. The std::map requires that each key be
unique. However, two keys can have the same value.
How will you handle the collating of pairs with
the same value but different keys?

If you _really_ want to sort the map, what you are
saying is that you want the data in the map to
be sorted by value. Easy, copy the data into
a new std::multi_map but swap the key with the
value before placing into the multimap. Or
you could use a list, or vector and a sort
function.

Search the newsgroup for "view pattern". For
a hint on how to make a "view" of the data
without altering where the data is stored.

--
Thomas Matthews

C++ newsgroup welcome message:
http://www.slack.net/~shiva/welcome.txt
C++ Faq: http://www.parashift.com/c++-faq-lite
C Faq: http://www.eskimo.com/~scs/c-faq/top.html
alt.comp.lang.learn.c-c++ faq:
http://www.comeaucomputing.com/learn/faq/
Other sites:
http://www.josuttis.com -- C++ STL Library book


Kevin W. 08-25-2004 06:20 AM

Re: Sorting a map by value
 
>> How do I sort a map by the value, rather than the key?
>
> You can't sort maps. They are always automatically sorted by key.


Yes, but I should be able to define the "less than" predicate in the
constructor, or I should be able to pass a custom predicate into the sort
function (as I understand it, you *can* sort a map because it is only
automatically sorted when pairs are added or removed).

What I'm really asking is:
What are the arguments to this functor (values, pointers or references),
and
How do I access the value from these arguments?

--
Kevin W :-)
Opera/CSS/webdev blog: http://www.exclipy.com/
Using Opera: http://www.opera.com/m2/

Philippe Guglielmetti 08-25-2004 06:58 AM

Re: Re: Sorting a map by value
 
25.08.2004 08:20:06

"Kevin W." <contact@in.sig> wrote in message

<opsc9yjw16jxvii7@localhost.localdomain>



> >> How do I sort a map by the value, rather than the key?




You need a different structure.

Have a look at the "bidirectional map" described on http://www.
codeproject.com/vcpp/stl/bimap.asp

Philippe Guglielmetti - www.goulu.net

Kai-Uwe Bux 08-25-2004 07:21 AM

Re: Sorting a map by value
 
Kevin W. wrote:

>>> How do I sort a map by the value, rather than the key?

>>
>> You can't sort maps. They are always automatically sorted by key.

>
> Yes, but I should be able to define the "less than" predicate in the
> constructor


Yes, this less_than predicate will be used to compare the keys.

> or I should be able to pass a custom predicate into the sort
> function (as I understand it, you *can* sort a map because it is only
> automatically sorted when pairs are added or removed).


The std::map<Key,T> container is a sequence of pairs. The type of these
pairs is std::pair<const Key, T >. Please note the *const*. Because of this
'const', you cannot change the keys once they are inserted into the
sequence. It follows that you cannot feed a segment of a map into
std::sort(). The swaps that std::sort() wants to perform are barred by
constness of keys.


Best

Kai-Uwe Bux

Richard Herring 08-25-2004 11:19 AM

Re: Sorting a map by value
 
In message <opsc9yjw16jxvii7@localhost.localdomain>, Kevin W.
<contact@in.sig> writes
>>> How do I sort a map by the value, rather than the key?

>>
>> You can't sort maps. They are always automatically sorted by key.

>
>Yes, but I should be able to define the "less than" predicate in the
>constructor,


Yes, and it defines the ordering for the lifetime of the map. Once
established, you can't change it.

>or I should be able to pass a custom predicate into the sort function


No, because there _is_ no standard sort function which can be applied to
maps. std::sort() needs random-access non-const iterators.

>(as I understand it, you *can* sort a map because it is only
>automatically sorted when pairs are added or removed).


No. As Kai-Uwe Bux has pointed out, the key element of each pair is
const. But even if you could rearrange their order, it wouldn't do you
any good, because the key lookup algorithm depends on the elements being
correctly ordered. The next time you tried to access an element by key,
you'd get UB.
>
>What I'm really asking is:
>What are the arguments to this functor (values, pointers or
>references),


The same as to std::less, namely (const reference to) key_type, and it
returns bool. And it must implement a strict weak ordering:

a<b && b<c => a<c;
eq(a,b) && eq(b,c) => eq(a, c) where eq(a, b) means !(a<b) && !(b<a)

>and
>How do I access the value from these arguments?
>

The arguments _are_ the values (or references to them.)

--
Richard Herring


All times are GMT. The time now is 09:01 PM.

Powered by vBulletin®. Copyright ©2000 - 2014, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
SEO by vBSEO ©2010, Crawlability, Inc.